A children's book review blog

Bookish Dad

Honest reviews from a guy who has read The Very Hungry Caterpillar approximately one billion times.

Latest review: The Trumpet of the Swan → Read it

The Trumpet of the Swan by E.B. White — featured review
⭐ Editor's Pick
Featured Review

The Trumpet of the Swan: The Third E.B. White Book Is Secretly the Fun One

E.B. White wrote three books for children. As a culture we handed one of them a permanent seat at the head of the table (correct), gave the mouse one a movie franchise, and then agreed to never mention the swan again. I would like to for...

★★★★★
5.0 / 5.0
Read the full review →

Little House on the Prairie: Pa Builds a House and I Explain American History at 8:40pm

Somewhere around night four, my daughter stopped me between chapters and asked whose land the little house was on. She asked it flatly, the way she asks everything, like an auditor requesting a receipt. And the honest answer is right the...

★★★★
Full review →

Bunnicula: A Vampire Rabbit, a Paranoid Cat, and the Best Narrator in the Business Is a Dog

On Thursday morning there was a carrot on the kitchen counter with two fork holes in it. Nobody would claim it. I asked the room in general what happened to the carrot and my four-year-old, without looking up from his cereal, said "THE B...

★★★★★
Full review →

The Indian in the Cupboard: I Loved This at Nine. At Forty-One It Needs a Chaperone.

Somewhere around 1993 I spent an entire Saturday trying every key in our house on every locked thing we owned. Desk drawers, a toolbox, a suitcase in the garage that turned out to contain my dad's tax returns. This book is the reason. If...

★★★
Full review →

A Wrinkle in Time: Twenty-Six Publishers Said No. Twenty-Six Publishers Were Wrong.

Twenty-six publishers rejected this book. Twenty-six. Two dozen professional book-pickers, people whose entire job was recognizing good books, held A Wrinkle in Time in their hands and said no thank you. Then it won the Newbery Medal in ...

★★★★★
Full review →

From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler: My 8-Year-Old Read This as a How-To Manual and Honestly I Respect It

Somewhere around the third bedtime, my daughter stopped me mid-sentence and asked how much a train ticket to New York costs now. Not in a dreamy way. In a way that wanted a number. When I said I didn't know, maybe forty bucks, she asked ...

★★★★★
Full review →
Browse all 57 reviews →

From the Blog

All posts →

I Hate Children's Books That Make No Sense (My 4-Year-Old Disagrees)

One of my favorite parts of the movie "Elf".. actually scratch that. I'm a card-carrying Millennial. ALL of "Elf" is my favorite part. Do you know the part where they are introducing Buddy the Elf's dad Walter Hobbs to the viewers? They ...

Read the post →

In Defense of Junie B. Jones (and Other Bad Influences)

"Oh I would never read Junie B. Jones to my kids, she's such a bad influence!" If you are a parent of a 5+ child you've probably heard this before. Luckily I didn't hear it before I first started reading the Junie B. Jones series to my k...

Read the post →

Curated Lists

All lists →